Hugh Smith

Hugh Smith Paternal Family Tree

Hugh Smith Paternal Family Tree

Gale / Hugh Smith / /

There’s a lot of information on this. The last three of four generations before dad ended up including a lot of criminals. When I found out his biological father, George, murdered his younger brother Noah and spent ten years in prison for the crime (I guess murder didn’t get a life sentence in 1932) I officially threw in the towel.

There may be good stuff in his lineage (like fighting in the Revolutionary War) but I now have a clear understanding why dad left Tennessee behind and would never let it touch his family. I sincerely hope he did not know who his biological father was and I also hope he was still living in Virginia when all mess surrounding the murder was going on.

Hugh-Smith-Family-Tree-Paternal-lg

Hugh Smith’s birth certificate

Hugh Smith’s birth certificate

Gale / Hugh Smith / , , /

With the help of my friends at the Campbell County Historical Society I had found my dad’s mother. Eliza Jane Honeycutt born in April 1901, who became Janie Smith, and lastly Janie Cross.

What I really wanted to know was who my dad’s father was. The ladies at the historical society warned me that in 1920 illegitimate births were usually not recorded and often the children were raised as the grandparent’s late in life offspring.

For me it was a due diligence issue. Once I realized that my dad was probably born Hugh Honeycutt, son of Eliza Jane Honeycutt, I felt I had to try one more time with Tennessee Vital Records for a birth certificate. The ladies at the society rolled their eyes at the futility of my effort, but it was something I wouldn’t feel good about if I didn’t try.

So I filled out the little form again, sent my money again, crossed my fingers, and hoped for success.

On April 5, 2013 my efforts were rewarded. I received my dad’s birth certificate in the mail. Based on Eliza Jane Honeycutt they had found it.

Those words don’t convey the magnitude of this information. After staring dumbfounded at the certificate for several minutes, I ran to the phone and called Trulene to exclaim “I got it! I got my dad’s birth certificate.” She couldn’t believe it and wanted me to read all the details.

This may sound stupid for some, but as a mom myself, my heart melted at the idea of my dad arriving at 1:00 AM on September 23, 1920 in ElkValley to an unwed mother. I couldn’t help but think of my dad as a tiny, little guy who had no idea the mess he had entered the world in.

His mother stated his father was George Crabtree of ElkValley and aged 30 years. She was 18. I suspect she was getting some kind of financial assistance, maybe at a poor farm, and whoever had delivered the child submitted the birth information to the state.

It didn’t take a whole lot of checking to find out George had married Josephine Honeycutt in 1914  and already had two children with his wife when he got Eliza Jane pregnant. What a great guy.

So Eliza Jane had an illegitimate Elihu (pronounced Eli Hugh) Honeycutt who eventually became Hugh Smith.

Hugh-Smith-birth-certificate

I can find a lot of detail about Eliza Jane’s family – everyone except her. My suspicion, and this is only based on my gut reaction and what my daddy said, is that she became a black sheep in her family and was shunned so no one knew what happened to her.

I want to find out if she was in a poor farm after daddy’s birth. One of dad’s few comments on his early life was that there was a steady progression of new boyfriends through their house and he was sometimes kicked out if the new one didn’t want a child. So my thinking is she was rejected by her family over the pregnancy – which makes me wonder if there was some family connection.

The birth certificate said she was a housekeeper at the time of dad’s birth and George was a farmer. He wasn’t a farmer – he was not a land owner and worked for other people. I would love to know who she was housekeeper for.

So following more suspicions, I suspect Eliza Jane became Janie and met John F. Smith who was willing to marry her. I suspect John Smith abhorred the idea of her previous child. They then had a couple children – Clay and David – and I think dad became an unwelcome reminder of Janie’s previous life and was treated as such. Dad had really ugly stories from his grade school years that seethed with great hate from his parents.

Somewhere along the way Elihu Honeycutt morphed to Hu Smith on the 1930 Census and the Hugh Smith by the 1940 Census. I have to tell you, I can’t believe my father stuck with the name Smith since I figure John Smith was one bastard extraordinare. What else explains my dad never mentioning a man in his childhood? That man had to be horrible.

So I sit here as Gale Smith and I think there’s a good chance I should be Gale Honeycutt, because John Smith was NOT my father’s father. Or maybe I should be Gale Crabtree. Oh that’s just peachy – the name of some ass who girls pregnant while he was married and having kids with his wife. Just dandy.

Why is God’s name did he go with Smith when I think he had to abhor the man and never once mentioned him to me ever in any way?

The only thing that matters is that he was the man who was forged by the miserable circumstances of his upbringing and somewhere along the way he became Hugh Smith – a man of such strength, integrity, and character that I aspire every day to be half the person he was. I am the daughter he wanted me to be – I have honor, I have integrity, I have a strength of character that has carried my through crushing life experiences.

I would like to have the opportunity to ask him why he stuck with Smith when it probably came from an abusive man he detested. I’ll never get the answer to that question.

Elihu Honeycutt to Hugh Smith. My daddy. My hero. The finest man I’ve ever known. The father I adore and I still miss every day. I wish he was still here and 93 years old and driving my crazy. And trust me – if he was here and living with me he’d be telling me what was what and ticking me off and driving me crazy. And I’d be loving every minute of it. Kindred spirits. What can you say?

 

 

Information learned in Tennessee Part 4

Gale / Hugh Smith, Smiths / , /

Because of the story mom had shared with me I knew dad had been married and divorced before WWII so I looked for that while I was in Tennessee.

According to mom the sequence was marriage, repeated infidelities by his wife, divorce, enlistment in Army, birth of child long after dad had disappeared from the scene.

I found the marriage record from February 1, 1942 and noticed she was older than dad. I also recognized daddy’s hand-writing:

It was a little creepy for me, but I found a family tree on ancestry.com posted by CharlotteMcGuire62 that listed dad as the father to Stephen Hugh Smith. Dad was the first of Jeanette’s 3 husbands (Charles McGuire had been her second husband). It listed dad’s birth November 23, 1906 and his death as February 1980. Not correct but close enough that someone had knowledge about him. But then mom had said a man had contacted her after dad’s death saying he was dad’s son and wanting part of dad’s estate.

Stephen Hugh Smith was born on December 20, 1942.

I couldn’t find the divorce, but dad’s induction date into the army as October 9, 1943.

So the actual sequence of events was marriage, maybe repeated infidelities by his wife, birth of child, divorce, enlistment in Army.

I was momentarily rattled when I ran across this, but in a minute I decided I didn’t care.

My dad was such an incredibly honorable man and good father that I believe he did the right thing back then just as he did all the time with us. I will never know what contributed to him leaving Tennessee for good and not having contact with anyone from there again. In my heart I believe he would never leave a child that was his.

Mom had said he never told us because he was afraid we would start to fear that he would abandon us too. When she told me I thought it was the dumbest thing I’d ever heard because dad was the most steadfastly loyal person I’d ever known and he would never have left us. After finding out the child was born before he divorced and enlisted I can really understand his desire to keep it secret.

The only question I have is who twisted the story? Did dad tell mom the straight story and she sugar-coated it for me or did he alter the sequence of events for her. My dad was almost painfully honest, so I suspect he laid it on the line for her. And I understand the sugar-coating. It was a bit of shock, but when all is said and done I trust my dad.

I did research and Stephen Hugh Smith served in Vietnam and died at the age of 55 in 1998 so I will never know what happened.

 

Information learned in Tennessee Part 3 – the Honeycutts

Information learned in Tennessee Part 3 – the Honeycutts

Gale / Hugh Smith, Smiths / , , /

The Honeycutts

Trulene and I started to search for Janie Honeycutt in 1920. Once again, I had no success because of being too literal. Trulene found her family on the 1920 census and discovered Janie was actually Eliza Jane.

[table id=5 /] [wpdm_file id=17]

 

Some things I noticed — Ida Belle was probably 15 when they married because she was 16 when the first child was born. The Honeycutts lived on Capuchin Creek Rd. and Trulene told me it’s so remote that even today no one hardly ever goes out that far.

1910 Census

Trulene found the 1910 census next, even with a change in names. This census was taken on May 2nd where the 1920 census had been taken on January 19th so there was a slight shift in ages. If you look at the census page image note the 11 and 13 year old boys are farm laborers now but listed as still attending school. Eliza Jane could read but not write at 8 years old.

[table id=6 /] [wpdm_file id=17]

 

 1900 Census

Some observations — Ida Belle was 17 years old with a 3 and 2 year old on June 14, 1900. The census said both James and Ida Belle could read but not write.

[table id=7 /] [wpdm_file id=19]

 

1895 Marriage of James Honeycutt and Ida Bell Roysden

There’s several things about this document that annoy me. Ida Belle’s name isn’t even spelled correctly, no signature was required by the bride-to-be, and it’s almost like she was sold to him. What can I say? It was 1895 in rural Tennessee.  Ida Belle was born on 7/13/1880 and James on 4/26/1875 so Ida Belle was 4 months short of her 15th birthday when she married. The entire entry is in the same handwriting so this would back up that neither James nor Ida Belle could write.

 

[wpdm_file id=20]

1930 Census

Trulene, being a thorough researcher, wanted to find the 1930 census to verify that Eliza Jane was no longer listed there. Despite the census taker entering the name as James Heneycutt Trulene was able to find the record.

One the 1930 census they asked the age at marriage and the put 18 and 14. That is incredibly young. Apparently the son John who was 1 year old on the previous census did not survive. Daisy, the youngest child, must have been on the next page of the census and wasn’t listed. She was born in 1922.

[table id=8 /] [wpdm_file id=21]

 

One last document I found from the Honeycutts — the WWI draft card for James Honeycutt. Look at the eye and hair color. Yellow eyes and black hair. Yellow eyes? That’s a new one and I wonder if it was true.

 

Question remains

This was all interesting genealogy of my dad’s maternal side, but it didn’t get me any closer to finding out who the father may have been to Eliza Jane’s child.

Trulene and other ladies at the historical society told me it was common practice back then that when a daughter got pregnant out of wedlock the child would be raised as the parent’s child, not the daughter’s. This was viewed as more socially acceptable.

They also told me it was common place for the girls to never tell anyone who the father was. I couldn’t understand why a case of teenage hormones had to be kept in such secrecy until they explained that more often than not the father was a married man. So the girls protected the cheating, predatory male with their secrets.

But what little dad said about his early childhood sounded like it was he and his mother and no mention of anyone else around so I wondered if she had left home after the birth of the child. Trulene said there was a chance there might be a court record if she had to apply for welfare for herself and the baby so I decided make a trip to Scott county.

 

My tour of dad’s childhood area Part 2

My tour of dad’s childhood area Part 2

Gale / Hugh Smith, Smiths / , , /

 

Link to slide show of photos and maps of the tour

Lick Fork at dad’s address in 1940

Dad’s address in 1940

There is a mine located across the street from319 Lick Fork Rd.and nothing on the 319 side of the road. I found out the mine is no longer in operation. I suspect the mine had housing across the street for the miners who worked for them and that’s why my dad’s family had lived there.

I had read an article at the historical society that mining companies would pay the miners with tokens that could only be spent at their company store. They provided housing that the miners had to pay them to rent. It was a closed economy with the mine in complete control of almost every aspect of the workers lives. I suspected the housing was not very nice.

[wpdm_file id=22]

 

If you follow Lick Fork Rd.out a bit further than I went it turns into Capuchin Creek Rd.which where the Honeycutt farm was. That explains how John Smith and Eliza Jane Honeycutt may have met.

After pictures I drove out to where Lick Fork, Elk Fork and 297 intersected to followed Elk Fork to the correct church and cemetery.

Valley View Cemetery

Valley View Cemetery is just that – a cemetery nestled in a narrow valley. It was a much larger cemetery – large enough I was worried about finding the grave makers I was looking for. After getting yelled at when taking pictures at the previous cemetery I immediately walked to the back where I heard men working and asked if it was okay for me to walk around and take pictures. I could tell they thought it was weird I even asked. Go figure.

I started at one side walking the full length of the cemetery row by row. I finally found Clay Smith on the next to last row. Next to him was his father John F. Smith. I have nothing against Clay Smith but when I looked at the marker for John Smith I thought this is the man who must have been so awful to my father that he would grow up and never utter a word about his step-father to his own children. I resisted the impulse to spit on his grave and took pictures instead.

Elk Valley

I left the cemetery and took 297 north toward Jellico. I passed through Elk Valley shortly after getting back on 297. The population is supposed to be 4000 but it was barely a wide spot in the road, so I don’t know if they include a large part of the rural area.

Jellico is the town I remember my dad talking about, telling people it was where he was from. I got Oneida from the ship passenger list when dad returned from Germany since he stated that as his birth place and the funeral book when dad died also said he was born in Oneida. Elk Valley is what dad listed as his home town when he enlisted in the army. I have no recollection of him mentioning either one.

Rector Cemetery

I still hadn’t found the cemetery where the Honeycutts were buried so I went back to the motel to see if I could get a better idea of where it was located and went back toward Huntsville that evening to find it. I had no idea who these people were or what, if any, part they had played in my dad’s life, but I wanted to get pictures for the sake of genealogy.

I had to take Norma Road south from Norma on Rt 63 and find Straight Fork Rd. Whoever named Straight Fork had a sense of humor since it twisted and turned all over the place.

I found Cemetery Rd and Rector Cemetery with the help of the GPS. It was such a little road I would not have realized I’d missed it without seeing it go by on the GPS.

This cemetery was a little scary to me since I was alone way out in a rural area where the houses reflected abject poverty. I quickly found the graves, took pictures, and got back in the car to head back to civilization. It surprised me how nervous it made me. I have traveled extremely remote areas alone and not been spooked, but this place did. Maybe it was some of the scruffy men I had seen outside of houses on the way there. Maybe it was the stories my dad had told me and the impression I had of the area. Who knows, but I was so glad when I was back on 63 and headed toward I-75.

I would go back to the historical society the next day to see what more I could find out before heading home.

 

1 2 3 4 5